Delving into Mahatma Gandhi’s complex legacy, we explore the ideological divides that his leadership fostered, notably through his responses to critical events such as the Jallianwala Bagh Massacre and Bhagat Singh’s execution. These moments underscore the challenges of applying moral ideologies within colonial rule’s harsh realities. This examination not only revisits Gandhi’s celebrated principles but also confronts the nuanced debates surrounding his influence, offering a comprehensive view of a figure who profoundly shaped history through his divisive ideologies.